Simon PLC Attorneys & Counselors – October 2023 Memorandum
Michigan Receivership Authority: Rejection of Executory Contracts and Leases
Troy, MI – In the realm of distressed assets and court supervised liquidations, the appointment of a receiver is not an uncommon occurrence. A court-appointed receiver is a neutral third party entrusted with the responsibility of managing and safeguarding assets or properties. Typically, a receiver is appointed when there is a commercial loan default, partnership dispute, or business dissolution.
Under Michigan’s Receivership Act, the authority to appoint a receiver is notably broad. The Act provides that a receiver can be appointed in connection with the enforcement of any security agreement or lien (see MCL 554.1016(2)). For example, a claim and delivery action—a legal remedy less cumbersome than foreclosure—may result in a receiver’s appointment. This statutory flexibility is particularly beneficial for commercial and industrial (C&I) lenders who hold mortgages on commercial real estate, even if the loan is not a traditional real estate loan.
Importantly, the Act also recognizes that the appointment of a receiver can be agreed upon in advance. Specifically, Section 6(2)(b) allows a court to appoint a receiver when the borrower has expressly consented to this remedy in the loan documents. As a result, receivership can serve as a powerful tool in enforcing lenders’ rights and protecting the value of collateralized property during times of financial distress.
The authority of the receiver is broad and is based on statutes, case law and the order which appointed the receiver. This authority includes the ability to reject executory contracts and leases which affect the property in dispute. However, when a court-appointed receiver rejects a lease agreement, it can have significant implications for all parties involved.
Expanded Pathways for Appointing a Receiver
Historically, appointing a receiver in Michigan sometimes involved considerable procedural hurdles. Under previous rules like the Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act (UCRERA), courts often required creditors—particularly lenders—to initiate a foreclosure before a receiver could be put in place. This foreclosure-first approach meant a lengthier, more intensive process for many creditors seeking to protect their interests.
With the adoption of Michigan’s Receivership Act, however, the landscape has shifted. The Act allows for a receiver to be appointed much more broadly, including in situations involving the enforcement of any security agreement or lien—not just foreclosures on real estate. For instance, a creditor bringing a claim and delivery action, which is generally less cumbersome than foreclosure, can now seek the appointment of a receiver during that action. This procedural flexibility particularly benefits commercial and industrial (C&I) lenders who have secured their loans with both business assets and underlying real estate.
Another important update is that courts now have explicit authority to appoint a receiver if the borrower agreed to this remedy ahead of time in their loan documents. This contractual provision streamlines the process and empowers creditors to act more efficiently to safeguard collateral during financial distress.
Updates to Receiver Appointment and Qualification Process
Section 7 of Michigan’s Receivership Act ushers in several important updates to how receivers are appointed and qualified. Departing from previous practices outlined in the Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act (UCRERA), the new section now requires a more formalized selection procedure. Notably, the statute details a specific process for nominating a receiver and allows parties to formally object if they disagree with the court’s choice.
Under MCL 554.1017, courts are now obligated to take into account a defined set of factors when considering the appointment of a receiver. These factors help guide the decision-making process and are designed to foster transparency and consistency in receiver appointments. Additionally, if the court selects a receiver who was not put forth by any of the parties involved, there is an explicit path for objections—giving all stakeholders a greater voice and option for recourse during these proceedings.
Updates to Receiver Appointment and Qualification Process
Section 7 of Michigan’s Receivership Act ushers in several important updates to how receivers are appointed and qualified. Departing from previous practices outlined in the Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act (UCRERA), the new section now requires a more formalized selection procedure. Notably, the statute details a specific process for nominating a receiver and allows parties to formally object if they disagree with the court’s choice.
Under MCL 554.1017, courts are now obligated to take into account a defined set of factors when considering the appointment of a receiver. These factors help guide the decision-making process and are designed to foster transparency and consistency in receiver appointments. Additionally, if the court selects a receiver who was not put forth by any of the parties involved, there is an explicit path for objections—giving all stakeholders a greater voice and option for recourse during these proceedings.
The Formal Appointment and Objection Process for Receivers
Location’s Organization</Receivership Act> introduces a more structured framework for both appointing a receiver and raising objections to their selection, diverging significantly from the earlier Organization provisions. Under the Act, there is now a formalized procedure that must be followed when selecting a receiver. The court is tasked with weighing specific criteria before making an appointment, ensuring that the most qualified and appropriate individual is chosen for the role.
Importantly, if the court selects a receiver who was not nominated by either party in the case, the statute provides a mechanism for those parties to raise objections. This means that stakeholders are afforded an opportunity to voice concerns or challenge the court’s nomination, promoting transparency and fairness throughout the process. The court will then consider these objections, along with various factors outlined in the statute, before confirming or altering its decision regarding the receiver’s appointment.
Court Considerations for Receiver Appointment
When determining whether to appoint a receiver under Michigan’s recent statutory framework, courts are required to weigh several statutory factors. These may include the condition and value of the property, the nature of the default or dispute, whether appointment is necessary to preserve assets, and the potential impact on all interested parties. Each of these considerations ensures that the receiver’s appointment is an appropriate and equitable remedy in the context of the specific case.
Michigan’s Receivership Act, in section MCL 554.1027, specifically provides that a receiver may reject executory contracts, and which includes leases. Limitations to this power apply if: (a) The tenant occupies the leased premises as the tenant’s primary residence; (b) The receiver was appointed at the request of a person other than a mortgage; or (c) The receiver was appointed at the request of a mortgagee and 1 or more of the following apply: (i) The lease is superior to the lien of the mortgage; (ii) The tenant has a non-disturbance agreement; (iii) The mortgagee has consented to the leas…
Comparing Bankruptcy Court and State Court Expertise
It is worth noting that, while some state court judges possess a solid understanding of business and commercial matters, bankruptcy courts are structured specifically to address complex commercial disputes and facilitate the liquidation of assets with speed and efficiency. Their deep familiarity with insolvency issues ensures that cases involving receivers and distressed assets often progress more swiftly than they might in the state court system. This heightened proficiency and focus allow bankruptcy courts to navigate the intricacies of asset liquidation with a level of efficiency that is not always matched by general jurisdiction courts.
The Evolution of Michigan’s Receivership Act
The Michigan Receivership Act traces its roots to the Uniform Commercial Real Estate Receivership Act (UCRERA), which Michigan implemented in 2018. Initially, this legislation governed only receiverships involving commercial real estate, primarily offering guidance when collateral was tied to property. However, recent amendments—effective as of October 15, 2020—have widened its scope significantly.
Rather than being limited to commercial real estate, the Act now reaches broadly to cover both commercial and industrial (C&I) loans, even if there is no real estate collateral. The updated law, renamed simply the “Receivership Act,” empowers creditors by streamlining the process for appointing a receiver. For example, it allows for the appointment of a receiver when enforcing any security agreement or lien—not just in foreclosure scenarios. This shift reduces procedural hurdles, particularly benefitting lenders with security interests outside of real estate, such as those who have financed equipment or inventory.
Key Highlights of Recent Changes
- Broader Applicability: No longer restricted to real estate, receiverships can now arise from various types of secured transactions.
- Appointment Process: The amended Act establishes a clearer, more formal process for selecting receivers and provides all parties with the right to object. Courts are instructed to carefully consider specific factors before confirming an appointment, ensuring fairness and transparency.
- Notice and Reporting: The Act builds in safeguards such as requiring notice and the chance for interested parties to object before significant actions—like the transfer of assets—can take place. Additionally, property owners must provide comprehensive creditor lists, and receivers must report to the court on a quarterly basis, promoting transparency throughout the process.
These reforms aim to strike a balance between the interests of creditors, debtors, and other stakeholders. By doing so, the Michigan Receivership Act reinforces the court’s oversight while streamlining asset management and liquidation in commercial disputes.
Michigan’s Receivership Act, in section MCL 554.1027, specifically provides that a receiver may reject executory contracts, and which includes leases. Limitations to this power apply if: (a) The tenant occupies the leased premises as the tenant’s primary residence; (b) The receiver was appointed at the request of a person other than a mortgage; or (c) The receiver was appointed at the request of a mortgagee and 1 or more of the following apply: (i) The lease is superior to the lien of the mortgage; (ii) The tenant has a non-disturbance agreement; (iii) The mortgagee has consented to the lease, either in a signed record or by its failure timely to object that the lease violated the mortgage; or (iv) The terms of the lease were commercially reasonable at the time the lease was agreed to and the tenant did not know or have reason to know that the lease violated the mortgage.
Scope of the Amended Receivership Act
The amended Receivership Act, which took effect on October 15, 2020, has expanded its reach beyond just commercial properties secured by real estate. Previously limited to those scenarios, the law now applies more broadly to include commercial and industrial (C&I) loans, even if these loans are not backed by real estate collateral. This shift represents a significant development, impacting a wider range of financial arrangements subject to receivership proceedings.
Impact of the Receivership Act’s Expansion on C&I Loan Enforcement
Although the Receivership Act now expressly covers commercial and industrial (C&I) loans, this development does not dramatically alter the toolkit available for enforcing such loans. Receivership has long been an available remedy in Michigan courts for troubled C&I assets, so lenders and borrowers are already familiar with its implementation in distressed loan scenarios.
What the recent expansion does provide, however, is greater statutory clarity. By codifying receivership eligibility for C&I loans, the law helps eliminate lingering ambiguities for creditors, debtors, and for receivers themselves. This increased certainty aids all parties in understanding their rights and responsibilities when a receiver is appointed—streamlining what can otherwise be a complex and contentious process.
Receivership Authority vs. Bankruptcy: Key Differences
While Michigan’s Receivership Act offers a practical tool for managing troubled assets, it operates differently from a traditional bankruptcy proceeding. Receivership can serve as an efficient alternative for handling defaults, disputes, or dissolutions—often providing clarity and flexibility for creditors and debtors alike. However, it is important to recognize the boundaries of the Act when considering it against the backdrop of federal bankruptcy protections.
Receivership lacks several key mechanisms found in bankruptcy. For example:
- There are no built-in procedures for recovering preferential transfers made before the appointment of a receiver.
- The Act does not permit the broad use of cash collateral or provide a framework for debtor reorganization.
- Bankruptcy courts, by contrast, are specifically structured to address complex liquidation and reorganization issues, and their judges work with such matters on a daily basis.
Moreover, although some state court judges possess significant commercial expertise, bankruptcy judges routinely handle financial distress proceedings, making the bankruptcy court process particularly streamlined for unwinding or restructuring businesses.
In summary, receivership under the Act is a powerful state-law remedy—especially appropriate where swift asset control is needed and bankruptcy is not feasible. However, it lacks the full suite of remedies and protections that federal bankruptcy law provides. Parties should therefore weigh the unique features and limitations of each process when charting a course through financial difficulty.
Key Differences Between Receivership and Bankruptcy
While the Michigan Receivership Act grants receivers considerable authority in dealing with distressed assets, there are important distinctions between receivership proceedings and bankruptcy cases. Notably, the Receivership Act does not provide mechanisms commonly available in bankruptcy, such as the ability to recover preferential transfers, utilize cash collateral, or facilitate a structured reorganization of the debtor’s obligations.
Bankruptcy courts, with judges routinely focused on complex commercial and business matters, operate under a well-established federal framework that specifically addresses these issues. For example, bankruptcy proceedings enable the avoidance of certain transfers made before filing, leverage a debtor’s cash flow through the use of cash collateral (with court approval), and provide avenues for comprehensive debtor reorganization—all tools that state court receiverships generally lack.
Several factors may contribute to the receiver’s decision to reject a lease. A receiver may reject a lease if the terms and conditions are financially burdensome or unsustainable. This could include exorbitant rent, unmanageable maintenance costs, or unfavorable escalation clauses. The receiver’s duty is to act in the best interest of the assets or property, and if the lease compromises their value, rejection becomes necessary. In addition, if the lease agreement fails to meet legal standards or violates local regulations, a receiver may be compelled to reject it. This could involve issues like inadequate insurance coverage, zoning conflicts, or lease terms that contravene applicable laws.
If a receiver rejects an executory contract or lease, they are still responsible to pay the costs, charges and rents set forth in the lease and which accrued during the time of use and occupation of the premises. This basic proposition has been upheld by the United States Supreme Court, as well as other courts appointing receivers. Kneeland v. Am. Loan & Tr. Co., 136 U.S. 89, 98, 10 S. Ct. 950, 953 (1890). Furthermore, the fact that the Receiver may not have been in actual possession of the premises is of no import. Dayton Hydraulic Co. v. Felsenthall, 116 F. 961, 967 (6th Cir. 1902) (“That the receiver was not in the actual possession of the leased premises is not necessarily conclusive against liability. He was constructively in possession, for the decree appointing him described this leasehold by reference, and directed him to take possession”). These holdings are also supported by the Receivership Act, MCL 554.1022 which states that a Receiver may pay “in the ordinary course of business…expenses incidental to the receiver’s preservation, use, sale, lease, license, exchange, collection, or disposition of receivership property”.
The rejection of a lease agreement by a court-appointed receiver is a consequential event that can significantly impact the involved parties. While the receiver is a fiduciary for the benefit of all partis in the matter, such fiduciary obligations may dictate the rejection of a lease. This can lead to tenant displacement, additional legal disputes, and potential asset liquidation. It is essential for all parties to carefully consider the terms and conditions of a lease agreement and ensure compliance with legal requirements to minimize the risk of rejection by a court-appointed receiver.
N.B. Not Legal Advice: Please contact us if you would like to discuss the facts and circumstances of your specific matter. Simon PLC Attorneys & Counselors expressly disclaims all liability in respect to actions taken or not taken based on any or all the contents of this memorandum. The information contained herein may not reflect current legal developments and is provided without any knowledge as to the recipient’s location, industry, identity or specific circumstances. No recipients of this content, clients or otherwise, should act, or refrain from acting, on the basis of any content included in this memorandum without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from an attorney licensed in the jurisdiction for which the recipient’s legal issue(s) involve. The application and impact of relevant laws varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and our attorneys do not seek to practice law in states, territories and foreign countries where they are not properly authorized to do so.

